Trouble in paradise: SUVs in the Fan

suv_yikes.jpg

In the interest of full-disclosure let me say up front that, as a class, I don’t like sports utility vehicles. So, I wouldn’t own one. But my dislike of them goes beyond what I might choose to drive. At this point, I should also say that I love the Fan District; to me it’s as close to an urban paradise as it gets in this part of the world.

The first time I drove a SUV I was surprised at how unstable/top-heavy it felt. That was 10 years ago and the model I drove was a Toyota ForeRunner. Since then there has been plenty of publicity about how unsafe SUVs are. No doubt, some makes are worse than others are, but the basic full-sized SUV seems to be outrageously susceptible to rolling over.

Which is ironic, in a way, because many of the owners of SUVs say they drive them because they feel safer ensconced in their big-wheeled behemoths than they do in a standard sedan. Sitting up high they feel somewhat protected from the world of perils the drivers of smaller vehicles face.

About a month ago I saw a SUV get flipped over by a low-slung, compact sedan like it was a hamburger on the grill. The compact had been doing about 25 mile-per-hour before it struck the SUV on the rider’s side, chiefly because the SUV had run a red light.

The SUV tumbled over and spun around on its roof; its driver was bloody and trapped inside. She was lucky to be alive.

The sedan had a crumpled front end; its driver seemed unhurt.

As a bicyclist I’ve learned to watch SUVs more attentively than other vehicles. I don’t know why, but their drivers tend to be more apt to ignore me — because they’re not paying attention, or don‘t care — than drivers of other types of vehicles. Nearly every time a door suddenly swings open in front of me, it’s a SUV driver’s door.

When my neighborhood, the Fan District, was designed, most families didn’t own two or more cars. Some had none. Lots of people rode the bus to work. They had their groceries, etc., delivered. They walked for short errands. Consequently, the streets were much less congested with motor traffic.

Well, that era is long-gone, but there aren’t any more parking spaces in the Fan now than there were 50 years ago. So, it’s crowded. And, the bigger the vehicles get, the more space they take up, whether moving or parked at the curb. Not only that, the bigger — meaning taller — the vehicles get, the more dangerous it is to get around in the Fan, whether one is moving on two wheels, or four.

Why is that?

Lack of visibility. The height of SUVs, vans and other such tall motor vehicles breaks the sight line of one who is trying to see around them, especially at an intersection. For example: if you’re heading south on Stafford Street in your standard-sized sedan and you want to cross Floyd Avenue, you stop — look both ways — and if you see the way is clear, you step on your accelerator.

But if a monster-sized SUV is parked on the north side of Floyd, at the corner, facing west, you can’t see over the top of it, or around it. So, you either creep half-way into the intersection and look again, or you jet across, hoping for good luck to protect you.

While this scenario is an everyday thing for Fan motorists, it is dangerous and it could easily be prevented, or at least made to happen less frequently.

How?

Don’t let SUVs and other tall vehicles park within 25 feet of the corner. A law that says in the densely-populated Fan District motor vehicles that stand over a certain height can’t park near the corner should be enacted, ASAP. It would save some lives, prevent many an injury and it would improve the quality of life.

Of course, some SUV owners would object, strongly, but so what. They can park their gas-guzzlers in the middle of the block, or in their garage/back yard. Or, they can trade their dangerous oversized vehicles for another style of a ride.

It’s time for the people who live in the Fan District to ask the City of Richmond to pass a new law to stop tall vehicles from making it so dangerous to simply cross the street.

Bottom line: SUV owners have no intrinsic right to park them anywhere they choose. Move them back from the corners 25 feet and we’ll all be safer.

– words and manipulated SUV image by F.T Rea

Posted in Features, The Slant

6 Comments.

  1. Agreed. SUVs suck.

    Scott Burger @ June 13th, 2007 at 3:07 pm

  2. It does suck when an SUV is parked on the corner. I guess as an SUV owner it would be the end of the world if I couldn’t park on a corner. I don’t think an SUV owner purposely looks for a corner to park on or do we think we can park anywhere. As crowded as the fan is for parking – I think no matter if I’m in my SUV or my Wifes Volkswagon – I just look for a spot.

    It would be interesting to see if their are any facts on how many intersection accidents occur based on not being able to see do to visual obstructions.

    Eric @ June 13th, 2007 at 3:34 pm

  3. This has been done elsewhere, long before SUVs started rolling of the line in volume…when I got my driver’s license in TX 15+ years ago, I believe it was law that one not park any vehcile with 10 or 12 feet of a stop sign/light, for exactly the reason you describe.

    Brenda P @ June 13th, 2007 at 8:43 pm

  4. “Bus” is a near miss, friend. The Fan is a classic street car suburb. Your point is still right-on: Our (oh, oops, I live south of Main: “your”) fine, tree-lined, sometimes narrow streets certainly weren’t designed to hold personal vehicles at the rate of 2 or 3 per household.

    Lisa K @ June 14th, 2007 at 8:04 am

  5. Right on, solutions to this growing problem could include charging more money for fan parking permits for suv owners.

    Christopher Dorsey @ June 15th, 2007 at 6:07 pm

  6. A good idea would be to charge tolls according to the size of car. the larger the car the more the charge, this money should go to pay for public transportation within the city. if driving walking or bikeing to work every day i find it staggering the amount of suv’s on the road. It is bad for the earth and air, they take up to much space on the road, and up to three parking spots.

    Christopher Dorsey @ July 8th, 2007 at 2:37 pm

3rd Column

RVABlogs »

  • ::
  • ::
  • ::
  • ::
  • ::
Once Upon a Vine