Sunlight in 2009

eyes1aaa.jpg

“Sunlight is said to be the best of disinfectants.”
– Justice Louis Brandeis

Over the last year, what had been an ambient longing for cultural and political change coalesced. The voters willingly took a leap of faith. But what happened on election day, with its dramatic mandate for change, wasn’t the fickle result of a tidal wave. It came from what had been a long steady rain.

With high-profile executives under fire in many quarters, 2008 has proven to be a bad year for bad leaders. In both the private and public sectors incompetent leadership has been denounced bitterly.

Just as the nation is now eagerly watching President-elect Barack Obama for signs of hope that change will mean brighter days ahead, Richmonders have their eyes on Mayor-elect Dwight Jones. Coincidentally, or not, Obama and Jones are both following executives whose once-shimmering luster of popularity has faded to black.

Now Dwight Jones has the power to make a savvy move that would put him in a good light, as he prepares to take office with the new year. He could act boldly to show everybody in town, including current and future employees of The City of Richmond, just how willing he’s going to be to break with the yesterday’s cloistered way of doing the people’s business.

Jones could say, “Let there be sunlight.”

Or, Jones could blow off the opportunity, to stick with the traditional way of running governments that has wanted as little kibitzing from John Q. Public as possible.

Whatever Jones does, “sunlight” is a political issue that is only going to get bigger.

Today’s technology makes it possible for City Hall to open itself up to scrutiny from any citizen with access to the Internet. If Richmond wants to do it in 2009, this city could allow the taxpayers to follow their money through the machinery of government to where it gets spent.

Of course most of us wouldn’t actually put in much time doing that, even if we could. While some of us couldn’t make much sense out of looking at such data, in the first place, some watchdog individuals/groups will understand it just fine. They will be more than willing to take the time to do it, too.

As fresh as that concept might seem to some readers, it’s been bubbling in the blogosphere for some time. One noteworthy and innovative step has already been taken toward more citizen oversight of routine government business. Last year Waldo Jaquith, one of Virginia’s best known political bloggers, launched a website to track bills through the General Assembly. It’s called Richmond Sunlight (click here to see it).

Yes, the same Internet that offers unlimited opportunities to waste time, could also be the key to making democracy function properly in the 21st century through swift and greater accountability. Besides, since the government already watches us all the time, why shouldn’t we be able to watch it?

Mixed in with all the gibberish spewed out by blogs, especially political blogs, there are cutting-edge ideas being discussed and pertinent new issues are solidifying. Attacking and defending ideas is a healthy exercise, whether it is done stylishly or not. Only Luddites, who are deliberately ignoring the blogging phenomenon, are still saying political blogs don’t matter.

In Richmond no one has written more eloquently about the beauty of sunlight/transparency into matters involving the use of public funds than freelance writer Don Harrison, who publishes Save Richmond (click here to see it), which won the Laurence E. Richardson Freedom of Information Award (it was Harrison and two partners then) in 2005 for its investigative journalism.

Harrison knows how to wield Freedom of Information Act requests and he’s earned a following in the local blogosphere with his revealing posts about the Virginia Performing Arts Foundation/CenterStage, in particular, and about local politics, in general. He has argued convincingly that if public money is being used, the public has the right to see the books.

Yet, the VAPAF — even after having been caught fudging money matters — still seems to be resisting the call to stop concealing what money it has, or how it is being/will be spent. Harrison says the game has now been rigged to shield VAPAF from future FIOA requests.

It would be a sure sign of brighter days ahead if Mayor Jones moves to undo that particular mistake on his first day in office.

Moreover, there’s an unorganized band of dogged bloggers in Richmond who pay way more attention to local politics than just about anybody, including most staff writers at local newspapers and magazines. (Click here to see an example of what’s happening at Church Hill People’s News, published by John Murden).

The assertion that sunlight is the key to creating more efficient governments, from the bottom up, instead of from the top down, is all over the blogosphere.

It won’t be long before ambitious candidates catch on to this movement toward openness. Soon, as a campaign issue, advocating more sunlight into government’s handling of money is going to get politicians elected, whether they are liberals or conservatives.

Just how this citizen oversight of the flow of money would be accomplished, technically, is something best left to the IT experts. But if Mayor-elect Jones wants there to be a portal through which we can view how his administration handles money, and weigh that performance, he can make it happen.

In the long run sunlight should promote more honesty and greater competence in government offices. It should facilitate a better informed citizenry. Part of the answer to the mind-boggling trouble with money this nation is facing in 2008 is more sunlight in 2009.

– 30 –

 – Words and art by F.T. Rea

Update:

At Tertium Quids prolific blogger and think tank cat Norm Leahy writes about the sunlight/transparency issue; click here to read his post.

Posted in Features, RVANews-politics

9 Comments.

  1. “It won’t be long before ambitious candidates catch on to this movement toward openness.”

    You got that right…

    john m @ December 17th, 2008 at 2:43 pm

  2. John,

    The potential of “sunlight” as a populist issue is unlimited.

    It’s a concept that defies the old-think pols’ view of issues that wants to cast everything in a left/right lines context.

    FTRea @ December 17th, 2008 at 3:01 pm

  3. I want that sunlight badly in RPS. Scratch the surface and up comes sewage and I’m not talking about the kids, teachers, or even parents -haven’t had any problems there. I won’t give specifics now but just a couple of suggestions: 1) Have parents fill out exit surveys when they choose to leave a school 2) Have the basic information from surveys made public just like the SOL scores – information such as “unqualified principal,” “resource shortage,” “safety concerns,” “moved,” etc. 3) Make public the number of teachers leaving a school and why -something simple again like “because of principal,” “promotion,” “moved,” etc.

    gray @ December 17th, 2008 at 4:23 pm

  4. Quite the contrast between this post and one in ‘Barticles’:

    http://barticles.mytimesdispatch.com/index.php/barticles/comments/world-class_corruption/#comments

    Scott Burger @ December 17th, 2008 at 5:28 pm

  5. Excellent piece, Terry. If Jones seizes this opportunity, he would earn the respect of people like me almost instantly.

    There’s an effort to expand transparency at the state level — my group is pushing for it in a big way in the next GA session.

    Norm leahy @ December 18th, 2008 at 10:50 am

  6. Thanks Terry. I believe we can bring transparency to government whether or not elected officials embrace it. Don and other whistle-blowers have proven that information is power. I feel the same regardless of who sits in the Mayor’s office: if they refuse to open up the doors, we will knock them down.

    Whether it’s city finances, public schools, project proposals, choosing a police chief, our elected officials should be accountable for everything they do in office.

    It’s time for citizens to insist on accountability and transparency. The truth is a virus!

    Rabbit @ December 18th, 2008 at 12:09 pm

  7. … and now this.

    Rabbit @ December 19th, 2008 at 1:45 pm

  8. Rabbit,

    The story about cops-gone-wrong your link reveals is one I suspect is going to make a lot of people ask questions about. Why it sat around for nearly a year is just one of the baffling aspects of this case.

    However, the failure of the mainstream media to notice this troubling case aside, I don’t think this is all that unusual, in that cops in any town stick together. And, their bosses tend to let them cover up such mistakes.

    Which, of course, is why there should be a reasonable amount of civilian oversight of how police departments are operated. After all, we sure can’t count on our shriveling daily newspaper to be much of a watchdog, anymore.

    FTRea @ December 19th, 2008 at 2:22 pm

  9. it would be nice to have more sunlight in regards to govt. budgets, the drawback is that its hard to understand all the numbers to a layman, and budgets tend to be very long, boring.

    I think the sunshine metaphor also applies to free speech issues. In my opinion “hate speech” should be allowed because I want these types of peope exposed to sunlight not hiding in the shadows. Its hard to fight a shadow, but in the sunlight you can combat things like racism and let racists expose themselves for what they are…fools.

    Liberty @ December 20th, 2008 at 12:25 pm

3rd Column

Once Upon a Vine