Eliza’s Question: Unveiling Virginia’s new Civil Rights Memorial

jones350.jpg

Eliza asked her mother, “Where’s Rosa Parks?”

In January of 2002, Eliza’s investigation of the grassy rolling hills of the grounds of Capitol Square, which had recently become her yard, had aroused her curiosity.

The youngest daughter of Virginia’s 69th governor, Mark Warner, had noticed that among the six statues of people around what would be her home for the next four years, not only were there none honoring a female, there were none remembering the heroines/heroes of the Civil Rights Era.

“It started me thinking,” said Lisa Collis, Eliza’s mother and then Virginia’s First Lady.

Collis’ thinking eventually led her to consult with people who might help fill in the gap in Virginia’s history her daughter had innocently discovered in the statuary of Capitol Square.

*

On Monday a new monument for Capitol Square will be dedicated. The Virginia Civil Rights Memorial, a sculpture by Stanley Bleifeld, will commemorate a turning point in history — a 1951 student demonstration which was led by a 16-year-old girl named Barbara Johns.

To protest the outrageously deplorable conditions in which they found themselves at Robert R. Moton, an all-black school in Prince Edward County, the students staged a “walk-out.” Although it was change they were seeking, those brave students had no way to know where their peaceful demonstration’s walk would lead. They took those first steps not knowing that much of the worst violence of the Civil Rights Era was still to come.

Eventually, those students’ cause was taken up by civil rights attorneys Oliver Hill and Spottswood Robinson. The Moton case was folded into four other similar cases to be argued before the Supreme Court as one. The result: The 1954 decision in Brown vs. Board of Education of Topeka ended the days in which separate-but-equal could be used as the underpinning for segregation in public schools.

*

During 2003 Collis held informal discussions with various people to explore the possibility of a creating a memorial to key civil rights heroes in Virginia’s history, how to raise the money, possible subjects, etc. In 2004 she put together an exploratory group that included: Chief Justice Leroy Hassell; Secretary of Administration Sandra Bowen; Sen. Henry Marsh; Del. Preston Bryant; Clarence Dunnaville; Mrs. C. Howell; Mrs. Robby Thompson; Mrs. Judy Anderson.

In January of 2005, Del. Bryant introduced a resolution in the House of Delegates calling for the establishment of a commission devoted to creating a memorial that would pay tribute in some way to Virginians who played significant roles during the fight for equal rights for all, known as the Civil Rights Era. His resolution was approved and Gov. Warner issued an executive order that established the Civil Rights Memorial Commission

When the Commission held its first meeting it was guided by an expert in the field, Joe Seipel (longtime chairman of VCU’s sculpture department, before taking a job in the university’s administration), to contact four particular sculptors to see if they would submit concept drawings. Of the three artists who complied, Stanley Bleifeld was selected.

Collis and Bleifeld visited the Robert R. Moton Museum in Farmville to see the site, look over the museum’s archives, and meet with some of the former Moton students, to get a firsthand perspective of the events the sculptor sought to represent.

In October 2005 the Capitol Square Civil Rights Memorial Foundation was established to raise the funds and manage the overall project. The fundraising goal was set at $2.6 million.

In November of 2006 the Commission approved of the final Bleifeld design with its 18 life-sized figures around a granite base and what inscriptions would appear on the memorial itself. Trips to Italy, where the individual figures were cast in bronze, ensued.

*

On July 21, 2008, at 10:30 a.m., millions of eyes — not just in Richmond, but all over the world — will be focused on Virginia’s Capitol Square. Among other things, they will see what good can flow from a parent trying to respond properly to a child’s question. The event will be the official unveiling of Bleifeld’s art, the Virginia Civil Rights Memorial. It honors the heroism of students, everyday people and famous civil rights attorneys — Virginians who made their world a better place.

Furthermore, this time the process was done right. So don’t expect a lot of howling about the art being bad, or how the location is wrong, or any of that malarkey. No doubt, some will find fault with it. But this thing was put together by careful people who knew it had to be done right.

No doubt, the fact that Richmond was once the seat of the Confederate government will be mentioned in all the news reports. We’re used to that being a part of any story about Richmond. This time it will be most appropriate.

While this one piece of sculpture hardly balances out the number monuments to the Lost Cause standing in Richmond, it does a beautiful job of representing how much has changed in this city since the last general was put atop a pedestal on Monument Ave.

*

Links:

Virginia Civil Rights Memorial web site.

Richmond Times-Dispatch article on the ceremony by Viola Baskerville.

Stanley Bleifeld’s web site.

More information on Babara Johns is here.

*

The Members of the Civil Rights Memorial Commission are as follows:

Governor Timothy M. Kaine, Chair.
Lisa Collis, former First Lady of Virginia.
Leroy R. Hassell, Sr., Chief Justice of the Virginia Supreme Court.
Judith C. Anderson, former deputy secretary of the commonwealth.
Dr. Woody Holton, professor of history at the University of Richmond.
Rita O. Moseley, a 25-year employee with Prince Edward County High School.
Bill Bolling, Lieutenant Governor.
William J. Howell, Speaker of the House of Delegates.
Thomas K. Norment, Chairman of the Senate Committee on Rules.
Jennifer McClellan, Delegate in the Virginia House of Delegates.

*

– Considerable help with the information presented in the piece was provided by Lou Arnatt Kadiri, the Foundation’s Executive Director; The image is from the Commonwealth of Virginia;

– 30 –

Posted in Features, RVANews-news

10 Comments.

  1. Terry:

    Good piece, and this recognition is long overdue, and young Eliza could be forgiven if she didn’t realize Ms.Parks wasn’t from Virginia–thing is, we had some quite courageous civil rights pioneers of our own.

    Maggie Walker held a boycott of the graduation exercises for Richmond Normal School in 1886. Authorities refused the request of 10 students, chief of whom was the then Maggie Mitchell, to have the event like the white students at the Richmond Theatre, 7th and Broad Streets. Black graduations were most often held at FIrst (African) Baptist, because the sanctuary could hold close to two thousand people.
    At the risk of getting their graduation credential denied, which would’ve been a huge blow in a community that valued education as a way up, the group of 10 held the proceedings at the inadequate Normal School assembly room.
    This was the first black student-led walk out in the nation’s history and 65 years ahead of those also courageous Prince Edward County students. The event also presaged Maggie Walker’s enormous leadership contributions here in Richmond, and throughout the nation.
    The latter day choice is nonetheless an excellent one, for many reasons, but it just wasn’t “the” first in Virginia.

    Then, in 1904, firebrand editor of the weekly “Richmond Planet,” John Mitchell, Jr. (perhaps related through cousinage to Walker), called a boycott of the segregated streetcars that lasted about six to nine months — “Let us walk!” he declared. This boycott was a half century ahead of Dr. King in Montgomery, Ala.
    The traction company, weakened by a bloody labor strike the year earlier, suffered and staggered into receivership.
    But the Jim Crow laws stayed in force, and Mitchell never rode a trolley again. He didn’t need to. By then, the publisher and banker owned an automobile.

    Finally, by way of complete tangent, if you ever went out to Regency Square in the early 1980s there was a sculpture there of some hippie-esque parents playing with their kids.
    This piece was the exuberant “Family At Play” and portrays parents enjoying a spring day outdoors with their children. The bronze sculpture caused a tremor of criticism because the family was dressed in jeans, shorts and t-shirts and seemed reminiscent of hippies.
    It was on a motor so it slowly rotated. The mother wore a tank top and this fascinated me and was a source of some controversy at the time, due to the woman’s apparent lack of upper torso undergarments.
    The sculptor? Stanley Bleifeld. The piece is now “in storage” last I heard, since Regency’s most recent makeover.

    –HEK

    Harry @ July 16th, 2008 at 10:12 am

  2. Harry,

    Thanks. The Maggie Walker story is new to me, but I had heard about the streetcar boycott. I believe there were other streetcar/bus boycotts before the Rosa Parks incident, but as they say — timing is everything.

    Don’t remember the Bleifeld piece you mention, at all. I hope it’s still around. Was it in bronze?

    With the Civil Rights monument’s dedication coming, somebody ought to dust that baby off and put it on display.

    FTRea @ July 16th, 2008 at 10:39 am

  3. From my family’s experience in poor districts compared to my friends’ experiences in the wealthier ones, Richmond Public Schools continue to be economically separate and unequal, which runs along racial lines in our city.

    gray @ July 16th, 2008 at 12:25 pm

  4. Gray,

    While I have no doubt that’s true, much has changed for the better over the years.

    This scribbler is old enough to remember when the first black kids attended Thomas Jefferson here in Richmond. While my ideas about politics were still forming, then, I can certainly remember thinking how brave they were.

    Yes, when it comes to providing equal educational opportunities to one and all, considerably more change is still needed. But the progress that’s been made in the decades since the historic walk those Moton students took tells us change is possible, even in Richmond.

    FTRea @ July 16th, 2008 at 2:13 pm

  5. I know some progress has been made but until all schools offer equal educational opportunities, I will continue to state the facts.

    Here are some economic and racial stats: http://www.richmond.k12.va.us/indexnew/sub/statistics/freelunches05_06.cfm and http://www.richmond.k12.va.us/indexnew/sub/statistics/ethnicstats06_07.cfm .

    Can anyone guess which school has one broken computer in a class or a computer lab with around 24 working ones? Guess which school’s PTA makes $80,000 in a night and which one has under $1,200 in it’s entire account. Which schools have a yearly mass exodus of teachers and which one has the most Board Certified ones? The list is long.

    Is it okay that a child in the east end receives a lesser education at his neighborhood school than a child living in the west end?

    gray @ July 16th, 2008 at 9:45 pm

  6. Gray,

    No, it’s not OK.

    But I’m going to that unveiling ceremony to applaud the bravery behind the story of what progress there has been.

    FTRea @ July 16th, 2008 at 11:34 pm

  7. I’ll applaud right along with you and I hope it will inspire others to work for progress. Thanks for writing this up.

    gray @ July 17th, 2008 at 12:07 am

  8. Great topic, Terry! Below is the full version of an essay I wrote at Secretary Viola Baskerville’s request concerning the activities that will take place on the 20th and 21st honoring Virginia Civil Rights Memorial. The RT-D ran a “condensed” nugget of this. I hope you and others will appreciate the undiluted version.

    Are Our Schools Better Off Today?
    Where Do We Go From Here?

    By Carol A.O. Wolf

    The late and great Oliver W. Hill, Esq. was my friend and mentor for the past 25 years and my most valued and vocal constituent for the past six.

    Thanks to Mr. Hill’s inspiration, unyielding expectations of excellence, and the unfortunate fact of his blindness, I received a most special education as one of his privileged “readers.”

    “We” read every word of Simple Justice, Richard Kluger’s 798-page legal history of the Brown vs. Board of Education case and subsequent legal decisions. Several times.

    To be sure, over the years, we read many other books, including Mr. Hill’s autobiography, The Big Bang: Brown v. Board of Education, and countless legal and political articles. But, we always returned to Kluger’s Simple Justice.

    On our third time or fourth time through, I asked why we were re-reading it. His answer was, as always, honest and direct: “Because we are not finished yet. We’ve barely begun.”

    And, it was on that day, when I finally “got” what he meant, that he exacted the only promise he ever asked of me. “Do not ever engage in a discussion of the re-segregation of Richmond’s schools – they’ve never been de-segregated.”

    Since Mr. Hill and I had ongoing discussions of whether our schools were better because of Brown and what he thought we needed to do to fix them, I feel safe proffering the following answers:
    Short answer: No. Our schools are not better off.
    Mr. Hill often stated that it was a “sad fact” that although the Warren Court used the Nine-to-Nuthin’ Brown Decision to open the front doors of the schoolhouses of k-12 education, Richard Nixon’s appointment of William H. Rehnquist and Richmond’s own Lewis F. Powell, Jr., to the U.S. Supreme Court helped render the Five-to-Four Milliken Decision (July 25, 1974) which essentially gave those schoolhouses legal back doors for great masses of the white and black middle class to escape the problems of our nation’s cities in favor of life in the suburbs.

    In his dissent to the Milliken Decision, Justice Thurgood Marshall noted that poor Negro children would continue to receive “the same inherently unequal education in the future as they have been unconstitutionally afforded in the past.” Justice Marshall further noted that “In the short run, it may seem to be the easier course to allow our great metropolitan areas to be divided up each into cities — one white, the other black — but it is a course, I predict, our people will ultimately regret.”

    Those who knew Mr. Hill well know that he was not a man given to recriminations. He maintained a cordial “Virginia Gentleman” relationship with Justice Powell. Yet Mr. Hill dryly noted on many occasions that, even though Powell, as chairman of the Richmond School Board, had not supported Virginia’s “massive resistance” to school integration, the board under Powell’s leadership did nothing to integrate Richmond’s schools. In 1961 when Powell stepped down as school board chairman, “precisely two black children” attended school with white students in the city.

    Ironically, compared to what it didn’t do for public k-12 education, Brown actually flung open the doors of higher education for African-Americans and for women as evidenced by ever increasing numbers of accomplished and successful attorneys, doctors, business leaders, educators, scientists, authors, journalists and, yes, politicians. Still, we have far more African-American males in our prisons than in our colleges and universities.

    Richmond’s problems are not unique. All one has to do is read the newspaper of any major city in this nation to see that we all share the same urgent and sad challenges.

    Despite dramatic academic progress and the real and hard-won achievements of dedicated teachers, students and families, we still have a shameful graduation rate, an abysmal dropout rate, sky-rocketing out-of-school suspension rates, and virtual total non-compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, thus denying “simple access” to our one in six citizens with disabilities.

    Where do we go from here?

    Before anyone goes crazy enacting NCLB sanctions and dismantling public education as we know it and the good people of our nation intend it, I suggest we revisit the Milliken decision and reconsider not only what Richmond and the region, but what the rest of our nation’s cities, might be like today had that decision gone the other way. Can we find a way to recapture that missed opportunity for equality?

    We can all begin by re-reading Simple Justice. Why?

    As Mr. Hill said: “Because we are not finished yet. We’ve barely begun.”

    Carol A.O. Wolf @ July 17th, 2008 at 7:43 am

  9. Carol.

    Thanks. And, I sent you an email about this.

    FTRea @ July 17th, 2008 at 3:16 pm

  10. Carol,

    Please start a write in campaign. I find it unacceptable that the only person to fight for ADA compliance wont be around when they finally update the schools. Don’t do it for me or you or anybody. Do it for the kids who need a tireless fighter such as yourself.

    Jay @ July 21st, 2008 at 8:30 am

3rd Column

RVABlogs »

Once Upon a Vine